Melt is the floor: what the metal alone is worth today. A coin's collector value can be higher (date, mint mark, condition). It is rarely lower.
Melt
$4,348
2026-09-21
Common-date retail
See the book
no vault of collector comps yet
A dealer's buy price sits under both melt and retail on purpose — that spread is the margin that keeps the doors open. Ours is listed openly instead.
What makes one worth more than melt
- Common BU coins trade a few percent over melt. 2006, the first year of issue, and proof strikes carry the real collector premium: not a melt story.
Quick check
Minted 2006–present. Not sure if yours is silver? →
Calculate more than one
Have several? Open the melt calculator, pre-set to American Gold Buffalo (1 oz) →
Related series
American Gold Eagle (1 oz)Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle ($20 Gold)Liberty Double Eagle ($20 Gold)Indian Head Gold Eagle ($10 Gold)
Have a box of these? We'll catalogue and value every coin from your photos. Coins never leave your hands.
Get the free Coin Value Starter →